Killing By Seattle Police Raises Questions On Use Of Force

By Phuong Le and Gene Johnson, Associated Press

SEATTLE (AP) — Two Seattle police officers who shot and killed a pregnant woman inside her apartment had less-lethal options and had been trained to deal with people showing signs of mental illness and other behavior crises.

Still, within minutes of arriving Sunday to take a burglary report, the officers drew their guns and shot 30-year-old Charleena Lyles with three of her four children inside her apartment.

Authorities say Lyles confronted the officers with two kitchen knives — less than two weeks after she had threatened officers with long metal shears when they responded to a domestic disturbance at her home.

The killing raised new questions about use of force by Seattle police as the department remains under federal oversight following a 2011 investigation that found officers were too quick to use it All Seattle officers now receive training on how to better handle people with mental illness or have been abusing drugs. One of the officers who shot Lyles had been certified as a crisis intervention specialist.

Officials say the officers had at least one less-lethal way to handle the woman they knew had a previous volatile encounter with law enforcement and had been having mental health issues.

Family members have suggested the race of Lyles, who was black, may have played a part in the shooting and want to know why police didn’t use a non-lethal option. Police officials and Mayor Ed Murray say an investigation is being conducted.

Police on Wednesday identified the two officers as 34-year-old Steven McNew and 32-year-old Jason Anderson. McNew was hired in 2008 and Anderson joined the department in 2015. Both are white.

At a vigil Tuesday for Lyles outside her apartment building, family members called her a good person and demanded justice.

Monika Williams, a sister of Lyles, described her as a woman who loved her kids and liked to sing and dance.

“My sister was so loving and caring,” Williams said. “If you met her you would be drawn in. She was always smiling.”

Throughout the vigil and subsequent march, the crowd repeatedly chanted “Say Her Name,” followed by “Charleena,” while people held signs reading “Black Lives Matter,” ”People with Mental Illness Matter,” and “Rest in Peace Lena.”

Detective Patrick Michaud said Seattle officers are required to carry a less-lethal option to subdue suspects and have a choice between a Taser, baton or pepper spray.

He said the officers who killed Lyles did not have a Taser and he was unsure which option they had at the time.

Near the beginning of a roughly four-minute police audio recording of the incident and before they reached the apartment, the officers discussed an “officer safety caution” about the address involving the previous law enforcement interaction.

The officers talked about the woman previously having large metal shears, trying to prevent officers from leaving her apartment and making “weird statements” about her and her daughter turning into wolves.

Seattle Municipal Court records show that Lyles was arrested June 5 and booked into King County Jail. She pleaded not guilty to two counts of harassment and obstructing a police officer.

She was released from jail on June 14 on the condition that she check-in twice a week with a case manager and possess no weapons “or items that can be used as weapons,” and take all prescribed medications, according to court records.

The audio recording and transcripts released by police indicate that the officers had spent about two minutes calmly speaking with Lyles before the situation escalated.

The transcript shows one officer yelling “get back!” repeatedly and Lyles saying “Get ready, (expletive).”

An officer said “we need help” and reported “a woman with two knives.” He urged his partner to use a stun gun but that officer responded: “I don’t have a Taser.”

Sue Rahr, a former sheriff who heads the state Criminal Justice Training Commission, noted that circumstances determine whether officers are able to use non-lethal force or resolve a situation without force.

Officers may be able to take their time to persuade a suspect who’s standing in the middle of an intersection with no one nearby to drop a knife, but that might be different in cramped quarters or with children nearby, she said.

James Bible, an attorney representing relatives of Lyles, said Tuesday that “the officers knew she was vulnerable” when they went to her apartment.

“When we call police for help, we expect protection, we expect safety,” Bible said. “It was their responsibility to protect her and they didn’t.”

___

AP writer Martha Bellisle contributed to this report.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More From CBS Seattle

Download The App

Listen Live