New York Giants (9-7)
After winning the Super Bowl last year, the Giants lost some key players to free agency. Still they started their season (6-2) and enjoyed a two-game advantage in the NFC East. But that lead evaporated in the second half of the season. The team was particularly inconsistent, blowing out playoff contenders one week and losing to mediocre teams the next. Ultimately it’s this inconsistency that has the Giants staying home during the playoffs. (Photo by Rob Carr/Getty Images)